The Secularisation of Christmas
Blogged by James Preece on 9th December 2010
The Shinobi is right, this yearly "oh no Christmas is being secularised" thing is getting tedious. The fact is that the secular world is secular and has been for quite a while and frankly we ought to be used to it by now.
Every year like clockwork somebody will get upset that about "Happy Holidays" and postage stamps with snowmen on instead of holy pictures because it's not fair is it - Christmas is ours and they are playing with it!
I can't help thinking we sound like a load of spoilt little children, we've got all these toys and we never play with any of them and then the moment the other children want to play with one of them we shout "hands off!"
We secularised the Sacraments, we turned the Mass from the Holy Sacrifice at Calvary to a big meeting for a group hug. One of our toys was called Confession but we secularised that by deciding we can talk to God on our own thanks and the priest is just some bloke in a box and if he's just some bloke in a box then we might as well use the box as a dusty old store cupboard.
We filled those cupboards with old books of chant that we don't need anymore since we secularised our music. We secularised our buildings which are no longer designed to lift the mind to thoughts of heaven but rather to be practical, functional structures like secular leisure centres.
We secularised our Bishops by turning them in to faceless managerial committees with just enough authority to tie their own shoelaces so long as they get it risk assessed first and certainly not enough authority to actually reply to the letters you send them about the Holy Days of obligation that we secularised by, well, not having them.
We secularised our schools, we secularised our charities and we secularised our families. Prayer? Sacraments? Feasts? Seasons? We barely even know what they are. Lent is when people tell me that rather than fasting they "would rather do something useful". Baptism is for getting children in to schools, no wait... these days, there are no children to worry about.
Every aspect of our "religion" is almost entirely secularised. All our "toys", our feasts, seasons, songs, art, history, devotions, prayers and saints are stuffed in a dusty old box in the corner. Barely played with in years and years. We are not interested.
Then once a year in comes a toddler... They pick up the bright, shiny, exciting looking toy in the corner and the say "Happy Holidays" and we pounce on them. Mine! Mine! Mine! Get off! Get off!
The fact is that we are only interested in it because they are. If the secular world didn't pick Christmas up and shake it around, most Catholics would give it all the attention they give the Ascension of the Lord.The Bishops would move it to the nearest Sunday and in the absence of the Coca Cola advert nobody would even notice. The only reason Christmas isn't languishing at the bottom of the toy box with the Ascension is that the secular world decided to play with it.
Until we start playing with our toys, until we realise that the dusty old box in the corner is filled with wonderful gifts that were given to us by a Father who loves us and wants to share them with us, until then we have absolutely no business telling people who actually want to play with them that musn't unless they use the right name.
We can't say that Christmas is about more than just a secular celebration when we have reduced all the other parts of Christianity to be entirely secular!
By the way, I spoke to Fr Christmas this afternoon on the phone (he and I are good friends) and he said that until the Bishops reinstate the Ascension, nobody is to give them any Christmas presents - they are not on the good list.
Ho. Ho. Ho.





Reader Comments
+8
RayOS said...
I think these comments are spot-on. Maybe the bigger question is - How do we get Catholics to start playing with these Christmas 'toys' again?
+
+13
Yorkmum said...
Well RayOS...
It's interesting that since the Pope's visit +Vincent Nicols and +Kieran Conry have both talked about Catholics standing out by showing their Catholic identity. I'm wondering if it is time to ask our Bishops to reinstate celebration of Holy Days of Obligation on the actual day, since attendance at Mass is certainly a way of showing our Catholic identity to the world.
+
+6
Richard Collins said...
James, I am in the tedious camp!
I do think we should sound off when religious images are replaced by profane ones. Apart from anything else, it's a chance for a good rant.
+
+7
Cavalier said...
Excellent post.
+
+4
Martin said...
The early church was very good at appropriating pagan festivals and customs and turning them into Christian feasts. Perhaps this can be done one day to Christmas?
+
+6
chrysostom said...
This is a brilliant blog and deserves to be very widely read; please draw the attention of others to it. James Preece has become compulsory daily reading for me: this article, which is so true, shows that he is an excellent writer. Thank you.
+
+2
Richard Collins said...
Thanks James, sorry to have misinterpreted, with you all the way.
+
+4
Mike Carroll said...
Excellent blog which I read yesterday & mulled over night.
You seemed to have put into very clear words what I have been trying to verbalise and get over to people for quite a while now.
In my head I keep saying we have to do something about this 'secularisation' of the Catholic Church and actually started to fight a couple of issues myself.
I then realised that the Catholic Church is run on four principles (there should be three).
1. The Bible
2. The Catechism of the Catholic Church
3. Catholic tradition passed down from age to age.
4. The Golden Rule of the Catholic Church
IF ONE PERSON DISAGREES WITH ANYTHING IN THE CATHOLIC CHURCH THEN THAT IS IT, FORGET ABOUT IT! IT COULD BE THE GREATEST IDEA OF ALL TIME. IT MAY HAVE SAVED THOUSANDS OF SOULS OR JUST MEAN THAT YOU COULD HAVE BETTER PASTORAL EVENTS AT YOUR CHURCH, BUT IF ONE PERSON DISAGREES THEN FORGET IT - IT IS ALL OVER!
I think it is worth remembering that we have to consider this golden rule before we go into battle, so that we know what we are up against and do something about it!
You have an extremely large readership and I do hope as many Bishops as possible
read this post! It may be worth emailing it to everyone of them to see if they do some soul searching.
+
+3
Sarah said...
Super post James. Everyone who agrees should copy it onto an email and send it to as many Bishops as possible, or stick it inside a secular Christmas card to them perhaps?
+
Billy Atwell said...
These are excellent points. I appreciate you writing on this.
I also get frustrated with liberal tv hosts tell us how important Christmas/holiday sales are to the economy and how we need to spur economic growth, so long as we don't call it Christmas! If they're going to strip MY holiday of its religious meaning, then they should not go about telling me how important my holiday is to our economy.
Our society needs to decide whether or not Christians have a place. Either thank us for soup kitchens, schools, hospitals, clothing drives, ministering to prisoners, a holiday that benefits the economy, or leave us alone. I'm just tired to being used and insulted at the same time. The former is fine, the latter isn't.
+